The Decemberists and I have a relatively short history together, but it is still longer than most. They were one of the first bands I started listening to that were not video game soundtrack composers, and Her Majesty may have been the first "indie" album that I actually ended up owning. I do not think it was until I heard both The Tain and The Crane Wife in 2006, however, that my appreciation and admiration of the band solidified, and I was able to go into their back catalogue and truly love what I heard. I loved their baroque pop, their sea shanties, and their prog rock tunes in equal measures. I still do, so I jumped on the chance to see them right in my hometown (ticket's were 'spensive, but I probably owe them more for all the piracy).
Despite arriving 45 minutes after the doors opened, I managed to secure a spot about five feet/two rows of people back from the center of the stage. At 8 o'clock on the nose, three girls walked out to the center of a stage. I do not know what I was expecting from a band called "Mountain Man," but this ensemble was not it, and even less so when they broke out singing what sounded like a Southern hymn in a cappella three-part harmony. The audience went dead silent, and the sound of their voices filling the theater felt absolutely ethereal. It set the tone for the rest of their set, which, aside from the occasional minimal acoustic guitar accompaniment, was characterized by the quiet admiration of the interweaving of these three voices. It was the kind of music so good and unexpected that I could not help but smile for most of their set, and it helped that the girls were quite personable, engaging the audience intimately. The farthest to my right, who seemed the most out of place with a very punk hairstyle, entertained the audience in between songs with stories of her hostel days in Boulder and dedicated the last song to "the twelve-year-old boys in the front." I would have loved to have seen them in a venue a tenth the size of this theater. Their set lasted a painfully quick half-hour, filled with folk inspired and vocal-driven songs which sounded like they would have been sung by the villagers of a remote mountain town. The highlight was when punk girl said they were going to play a Tom Waits cover, which was met with cheering and followed by a solo a cappella rendition of "Green Grass." Her light, pleasant voice was a far cry from Waits' gravel, but the song sounded no less haunting in her hands, which spoke both to Waits' talent as a songwriter and her talent as a musician.
Elyse, if you are not listening these girls, you should be. That goes for everyone else, too.
The minimalism of Mountain Man provided some decent contrast for The Decemberists' stage preparations, where a keyboard, organ, accordion, drum kit, double bass, bass guitar, violin, at least ten guitars, and other instruments I am sure to be forgetting lay. At 9 o'clock, we were greeted by the voice of Portland's mayor, who invited us to meet the people around us and wave to the poor souls in the balcony. Little did I know, audience participation would become a pretty consistent theme throughout the show, and I it made the concert a lot more fun. But I get ahead of myself. After a brief exercise in imagination, the band assumed their positions on stage and proceeded to play the opening track, "Apology Song," a.k.a. the one that begins with "I'm really sorry, Steven." Having the one track that features my name be the first one in the set seemed like divine providence, and it set the tone for what was to be an amazing show.
Colin Meloy was a great frontman. Much like the opening act, he did not shy away from interacting with the audience. He commented often about the proximity of the audience, at one point asking, "Were you always this close to me?" In response to being called awesome, he introduced the "sixth member" of The Decemberists, a girl playing violin in the background who, as I just found out, is also a member of Nickel Creek. At one point, he even switched the hats of two boys standing next to the stage. His amicability, and the good time that the rest of the band members seemed to be having, made for a warm atmosphere and really let the audience have a good time as well.
After "Apology Song," the band, expectedly, played some tracks from The King is Dead. I haven't listened to this album much yet. Though I do like it, so far it does not begin to compare to Her Majesty, Picaresque, or The Crane Wife. Energy-wise, these new songs also were the low points of the set for me. It was only when they explored their back catalogue that the show picked up in intensity and enjoyment. The first of the old tracks, this rendition of "We Both Go Down Together" was positively tame compared to what awaited us.
Picaresque turned out to get a lot of playtime, and no complaints here. Also, check out how good my spot was! The very next track they played was "The Bagman's Gambit," which featured an entire audience crying, "No, they'll never catch me now!", Colin Meloy hilariously stonefaced and standing at the edge of the stage, and a ruthless and spine-tingling climax of noise. From there, the band transitioned into hard rock mode, playing "Won't Want for Love (Margaret in the Taiga)," with Sara Watkins of Nickel Creek performing wonderfully as Margaret. My initial appraisal of The Hazards of Love was pretty lukewarm, but it has been growing on me a lot lately, especially as I have taken the time to listen to the entire thing nonstop. This track in particular is standout, and hearing it live solidified that, and made me wish that I could have seen the entire album played live back when they toured for it. This small taste was too tantalizing, and perhaps the biggest disappointment of the night was no sign of "The Rake's Song."
From hard rock, they veered straight into prog rock with the opening riff of "The Island," hands down my favorite track from The Crane Wife and one of my favorite Decemberists tracks period. They played the entire fucking thing, uncut and unbridled. Words cannot describe how awesome that was, seeing Colin Meloy not ten feet away from me singing, "Produced my pistol, then my sabre. Said 'make no whistle, or thou will be murdered.' LA HAAAAAA!" I sung along too, of course. As did most people around me. The only thing that would have topped this would have been for the band to play The Tain in its entirety.
"Los Angeles, I'm Yours," was a pleasant surprise from Her Majesty, which still holds a dear place in my collection. I really wanted them to play "The Gymnast High Above the Ground," which I believe was the first Decemberists song I ever heard, but that turned out to be the only Her Majesty track of the night. Still, the audience, and myself included, appreciated this brief foray into their sophomore album. Meloy's voice is as distinctive and impressive in person, but to hear him say lines like "an ocean's garbled vomit" and "has left me wretched, retching on the floor" in a live setting really enhances the impact of his lyricism and vocals.
They played a few more tracks from TKID, which, again, were well-received, but the highlight here was the inclusion of "16 Military Wives" in the middle. The song has a great beat for getting the audience bouncing, but the real fun came towards the end, when Meloy let the audience take over singing the "La di da di da didadidadi dum" part, cuing us to sing louder, then softer, then in a whisper, then to just think it, then to get louder again, then to shout it, then to let him sing it by himself, which nobody let him do.
Midway through the show, some guy made his way to the front and placed something on the stage. After he finished playing whatever song it was, Meloy picked up the cardboard sign and said, "Oh, Boulder..." He turned the sign so the audience could read "Play Row Jim" scrawled in marker, referring to the cover of the Grateful Dead song "Row Jimmy" that graced the B-side of their "January Hymn" single. He made some quips about how they were not prepared to play it at all and, tossing the sign aside, continued with the set. Well, guess what their first encore was?
I am no Dead Head, but that was an awesome moment. Still, nothing compared to the next song, which I, and many other I am sure, was looking forward to from the beginning--"The Mariner's Revenge Song." Before playing, Meloy explained that the audience would have to provide a sound effect for a particular part of the song, and that was to be the screams of people being eaten by a whale. We had a practice run as the guitarist prowled up and down stage, using his arms to mime the jaws of hungry whale. When the band starting playing, the song was as much a theatrical performance as a piece of music. Meloy was our humble and vengeful narrator, the accordionist sang the ghostly words of the dead mother, and other members joined in from time to time. Particularly entertaining was the bassist, who, after playing a great solo on his upright, proceeded to fall, bass and all, to the ground with the rest of the band as the whale rose up to devour the ship. And, of course, we were all screaming at the top of our lungs, as instructed. Prior to that, we had been dancing to the shanty, swaying in unison in 3/4 time, and singing along. The song was the climax of the night, and the climax of the song was the very end, as the instrumental outro prompted jumping and clapping from the entire audience, which grew more heated and frantic as the tempo increased to ludicrous extremes before the final double attack. I don't have a video, and the audio I captured sounds like absolute shit, because I had too much fun to worry about anything else during that song.
After another brief interlude of clapping and cheering, The Decemberists returned to the stage a final time to play their second encore, "June Hymn." After the nigh-exhausting frenzy that was "The Mariner's Revenge Song," this track, although melancholic, provided a nice period of denouement, giving me the space to appreciate the show I had just seen. If you haven't gathered such from my ramblings yet, these guys are amazing live, and I heartily recommend you see them as soon as possible.